...the change from "or" to "and" would be better. Unfortunately, that's not exactly what the rule is stating. The wording change would require both to be in play before one could move to a different tile/feature, but the intent of the rule is that one can be moved to a different tile/feature even if it's the only one in play.
The wording as it will be in the next CAR (assuming I don't change my mind again):"If the Mage or Witch figure to be played is already on a land tile, the player must move it from that tile to a different tile."
Quote from: obervet on April 14, 2014, 01:06:30 PMThe wording as it will be in the next CAR (assuming I don't change my mind again):"If the Mage or Witch figure to be played is already on a land tile, the player must move it from that tile to a different tile."I still hope the clarification will change this so that you use the word feature instead of tile.
I agree with feature as well, which we have been and will still continue to do so when we play.Since there can only be three outcome, CAR could be updated with a numbered list.1. If none are in play...2. If only one (Mage or Witch) is in play...3. If both the Mage and Witch is in play...
Stehen Hexe oder Magier bereits auf einer Karte, nimmt man sie von dort weg und setzt sie um.
If both the mage and the witch are already in play, one of them must be moved according the rules mentioned above.
As mentioned above, whenever a Magic tile is placed, either the mage or the witch must be placed or moved; if this is not possible (for instance, because the magic pawn cannot be placed in any city or road), the player must remove one of the two magic pawns from play.
For me this a strong indication for "moving to a new feature" instead of "moving to a new tile" because I can't imagine a situation in a Carcassonne game where there would be only 2 non-closed features with only 1 tile, but there could be situations with only 2 non closed features with more than one tile.
Started by rfielder
Started by jungleboy
Started by TimBoPavey
Started by dirk2112