Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - Bumsakalaka

Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5 ... 106
31
Reviews & Session Reports / Re: I Love the Landscape!
« on: January 16, 2024, 12:11:14 PM »
I like that shadow arc :)

32
Official Rules / Re: The Wonders of Humanity – Rules
« on: January 16, 2024, 12:10:13 PM »
The division can be made with "small lines" just as markings that this is a square space.
I think in near future HiG will need to decide, what to handle Dragon on Wonder tiles when they release C3 The Princess and the Dragon.
I think they will need to update rules are we do in The Wetlands. Meeple has to be placed visibly on one square space of double tile.
Then it will be clear also for farmers.
Special case is German Castle - meeple is placed logically to the center of double tile. 

33
Whatever decision is made, we should then update both Scoring_During_Turn_Sequence  and Order_of_Play accordingly.

Please @Meepledrone can you added it to the Scoring During Turn Sequence because I'm working on it. And you know what and where to set.

But I have another question.

In Scoring During Turn Sequence, each feature have "Feature Scoring row which indicate, which scoring rules affect value of feature. And also icons which scoring can be made when this feature is scored - Robbers / Castle / Teacher / And Ringmaster (added for now just for Vistas).

But this information is missing for Cemeteries and Haunted Castles. Should it be added also? I suppose then yes. Fortune teller scores 0 points for owner, which can fire Castle scoring. So it can be also for Exp 11 features, right?

34
For the game, every feature which is not completed and there is no meeple are unoccupied. Doesn't matter, if that feature is unoccupied from first moment, when tile with feature were placed and player not placed there a meeple, or it was Abbot removed during game, or it was Dragon which eat meeple or meeple was prisoned by The Tower expansion and there is other options how can be meeple removed during game from unfinished feature.
In the moment when feature is unoccupied and unfinished you can plece there a meeple via arrow:
   
Instead of placing your meeple on the tile just placed, you can place it on any unoccupied, incomplete feature (a road, a city, a field, a monastery, or even an abbot on a monastery or garden) anywhere in the playing area - so it doesn't have to be on the tile just placed. Please note that fields completely surrounded are not considered completed, since they are not scored until the end of the game.

35
Official Rules / Re: The Wonders of Humanity – Rules
« on: January 12, 2024, 05:29:19 AM »
I think this rule will be changed. Problematic is tiles which feature is going over multiple tiles. Like German Castles and fields.
Everything else is for my just square spaces where fairy protects only one of them and Dragon can eat only meeples from one space in one step.
Unfortunately we need to follow most recent clarification, which tells that dragon eat all meeples on a tile (even double tile) and fairy protects who tile (event double tile).
This is valid for all tiles which not have preprinted lines like in City of Carcassonne. On City of Carcassonne, there is obvious, which "tile" is protected by fairy, and where is placed dragon.

36
@Meepledrone please, why is phase 2 in Scoring during Turn sequence called: 'Round 2 - End of "move wood" phase' when it's written above
'Step 2A: Move the Wood (Prologue) - Before any figure or token placement action'

Isn't this correct name 'Round 2 - Start of "move wood" phase'?

https://wikicarpedia.com/car/Scoring_During_Turn_Sequence

37
Congratulations all participants, specially @Challa007

This year it looks like simple quizz...

But it wasn't.

Next quizz will be WiCa my friend and I will consult with her/him every question, doesn't matter if I play or not that expansions.

Well designed questions @Meepledrone which where simple, but they used edge cases of each expansions. Which was BIG fun.

38
Also, the C3 image of gardens is too large: https://imgur.com/a/bDJEYOW.

@Bumsakalaka Could you have a look at the garden symbols for C3 and th 20th Anniversary Edition? They are displayed bigger than the symbol for C2. The C2 symbol is the right size.

Ok. I will. Problem of C2 is that it's not croped. I'll fix it with @Snearone

39
I found Feature which is missing on Expansion List - Selector.
Reward like King / Robber Barron.
There are several expansion using this like
* Merry Men
* Hiker
* Praesidium
* Cleric & Serf
* Dragon Killers
* Angler and Fish Farms
* Bastions

and more

This will be fine to filter by this feature, find them and print them.



Do you think it's possible @wolnic

40
Ok. New suggestion:
https://wikicarpedia.com/car/Carcassonne_Order_of_Play_for_Discussion Expansion selector is not showed.

41
Official Rules / Re: The Drawbridges – Rules
« on: December 16, 2023, 06:14:56 AM »
Please excuse my image without any meeples on it!


Red places the CCCF tile and claims the city with his meeple.  On his next turn he draws and adds the Cathedral Tile and places his builder on it.  Then Green draws the Monastery Tile, places his Green meeple on the Monastery, leaving the road unoccupied.

On my Blue turn, I draw the Drawbridge tile.  As I understand the rules, I can add it to the incomplete Red city, and place my Large Meeple on the Drawbridge road!

The road is now complete so I score 2 points, and the Drawbridge is down because the city is incomplete, so I can also move my Large Meeple into the city!

Is that what the rules allow?


Imagine, that in that city is also Watchtower city tile adjacent to Cathedral. Can I move meeple there? As in the rules is not said , where I have to place my meeple or on which tile, I can place it elsewhere, but in the city. I'm pointing rules for City of Carcassonne, which allows to place your meeple to finished feature, without limitation of where.

42
It's a tricky question for hypothetical situation :)

43

Uff, and this will be followed by 10 extra super mega hard questions  O0

44
Thanks for change.

I left Exp. 11 unchanged: The Mist is used by Ghosts and Haunted Castles. Why would you need to include it in the selector? It doesn't score points for itself. If you select Ghosts, it assumes the Mist is present in order to activate their placement. Similar case for Haunted Castles in order to score points... If Mist would be the only item selected in Exp. 11, it would have no effect.

Yes, please add it. I will be needed by Obelisk Fan Expansion. And I'm thinking also for Vistas.

45
General / Re: What's up with the River in Big Box 5?
« on: December 12, 2023, 10:50:26 AM »
There are two types of people in this world; those who refer to the River from BB5 as River 3, and those who are wrong...
This made my day :) +1 merit

Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5 ... 106