Carc Central Community > Official Rules
Rules Questions for Hans im Glueck Thread
kettlefish:
question from whaleyland:
--- Quote ---Q: When playing with The Messages and The Robber, can a player's Robber follow either Messenger?
--- End quote ---
Chrisof Tisch contacted me,
so in a short time, I will have the answer.
kettlefish:
--- Quote from: whaleyland on February 13, 2013, 01:57:41 PM ---Q: When playing with The Messages and The Robber, can a player's Robber follow either Messenger?
--- End quote ---
Answer:
The Robber can rob points from both scoring figures - from the follower and from the Messenger (woman follower). If there are more than one scoring figure at the same space as the Robber and multible scoring take place - the Robber can only rob from one scoring figure for one scoring.
Telephone call with HiG - Georg Wild - 03 05 2013
kettlefish:
Here are some questions from Mr. Numbers:
And the answers from HiG - Georg Wild - Telephone call 10 05 2013:
Robber and Messages:
1. Robber stands near one particular counting figure and robs only it's points. In this situation it is possible that robber will stand on the scoreboard till the end of the game, if the player will decide not to move this particular figure.
Yes, it is possible that the robber would stand till the end of the game.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. Robber stands near any counting figure and robs any points that this player will receive regardless what figure player will move forward. In this situation robber stands near "virtual" counting figure and receive first available points (of course, according the rules).
No, the robber can only rob the points from the counting figure which is on the same space as the robber.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Robber and other expansions:
Part 1: Will the robber receive Wheel of Fortune or Fairy's (1 point) points? This action is performed before "place the tile" phase, so robber can receive this points.
Yes, the robber can rob the points.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Part 2: OR: robber can wait till the end of the whole turn and receive all points that this player will receive in this turn including Wheel of Fortune points at the start of the turn. The same applies to Catapult points.
No, the robber must always rob the next points that are scored. The robber can't wait for a scoring with more points. Each scoring is separated - that means for example each feature is scored individually. The same is with the Fairy-Point or with the Catapult points or points from the Wheel of Fortune.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Carcking:
Has this been asked and answered?
A Robber stands next to a counting figure on the scoring track. The counting figure scores mulitple features triggered by the placement of the current tile. The multiple features score different amounts of points. Does the Robber get to choose which score he will "rob"? Or does the scoring player decide which of his features to score first, and thereby dicate which feature the Robber will rob?
kettlefish:
--- Quote from: Carcking on May 10, 2013, 10:00:40 AM ---Has this been asked and answered?
A Robber stands next to a counting figure on the scoring track. The counting figure scores mulitple features triggered by the placement of the current tile. The multiple features score different amounts of points. Does the Robber get to choose which score he will "rob"? Or does the scoring player decide which of his features to score first, and thereby dicate which feature the Robber will rob?
--- End quote ---
I have three examples. I need some more time and then the thrid is finished.
Please look at the thread
Robber and Messages - Examples
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version