Carc Central Community > Official Rules

The Phantom Festival

(1/1)

Tilehunt:
Hey guys, so here was my question on bordgamegeek.

--- Quote from: BlueMeeple ---Here's a question about the rules when combining the phantom with the festival.
As a brief summary of the rules, the festival allows you to
(a) place one follower on a feature or
(b) remove one of your piece from the board
whereas the phantom allows you to place the phantom as a follower after your original turn.
In the festival rules (which I saw in carcassonne CAR) it clearly states to deploy one of one's own pieces. However, the phantom expansion was released after the festival so I was wondering
(1)does that mean you cannot place a phantom in the festival turn?
(2)if not, can you choose two different options? That is, can you remove one of your pieces and place a phantom as an extra?
The festival and the phantom keeps confusing me, so i hope i get an answer soon.

--- End quote ---
And this was what I got.

--- Quote from: DoomTurtle ---The festival tile does not change any rules when it comes to placing a meeple. You place a festival tile. You then place a meeple on a feature on this tile as normal. If you have the phantom, you can also place that. Or you can place the phantom on its own.

The only special rule with a festival tile is this: If you decide not to place a meeple on the tile, than you can remove one of your meeples from anywhere on the board.

So that's it. Place as normal and be done. Or not place anything and remove something.

--- End quote ---
But the harder I thought about it, I became more and more confused. According to the CAR:

--- Quote from: Complete Annotated Rules ---Question: Does the phantom have to be second to a true follower, or can it be placed in addition to a non-follower piece? The phantom may also be placed as a second piece in addition to the builder, pig, or any other “move the wood” piece such as movement of the fairy or placement of a tower piece.

--- End quote ---
So since removing a follower is part of moving the wood, should'nt you be able to remove a follower and place a phantom? Or am I missing something?

Linkback: https://www.carcassonnecentral.com/community/index.php?topic=374.0

Scott:
As the rules are worded, you would not be able to use your phantom if you remove a follower from a tile. However, it may be acceptable to do so. Perhaps kettlefish can get an official ruling?

kettlefish:
At Spiel 2013 in Essen - I will have my appointment with Georg Wild - HiG.
There I will ask him all the open questions about the rules...

Tilehunt:
Thanks kettlefish! I wish you could ask him if the wagon can pass through the little road in Inns & Cathedrals. Here was the question:
http://www.carcassonnecentral.com/community/index.php?topic=262.0

Navigation

[0] Message Index