Personal tile from Marcel Gröber

[Challa007]

we are still working on the rules -
do you have an idea how you would like to use your tile?

-----------------------

suggestions from the community are welcome...

[Challa007]

the final decision on the rules should be with Linksux and you, of course 

[Linksux]

Thanks!
These are all great tiles 

I think the rule you made for your tile is too negative
Your tile should be associated with something overwhelmingly positive 

Thus my counter-proposition:

Challa:  the giant helps farmers, i.e. on a field with a giant all cities score +1 point... Or (other possibility) to have the tile on ones field gives a bonus of +5 points...

I like the idea of one tile add a bonus and combine with others custom tiles add a super bonus

+1 point per cities is too simple and similar to the pig, maybe something with an impact on the point of the cities directly ?

My proposition : if a player place a meeple on the city of the giant’s tile (of course giant is not a final thing), the city can not be attacked by an other player.
 the effect can be canceled if an other custom tile is played: the player is allowed to place directly a meeple on the occupied city

Maybe too powerful ? I m bad as making rules I need to test thoses things


Envoyé de mon iPhone en utilisant Tapatalk

[Challa007]

you are right, that's maybe too powerful. May I suggest a sightly different version:

the giant helps a meeple cross the outer wall of the city, and therefore the meeple has direct access to the city.
This means when you add a "giant" tile to a city you can place one of your meeples on the city segment EVEN IF the city is already occupied.

[Linksux]

you are right, that's maybe too powerful. May I suggest a sightly different version:

the giant helps a meeple cross the outer wall of the city, and therefore the meeple has direct access to the city.
This means when you add a "giant" tile to a city you can place one of your meeples on the city segment EVEN IF the city is already occupied.

Yes I like it,
[mention]oldbonz [/mention] what do you think ?


Envoyé de mon iPhone en utilisant Tapatalk

[Sinscerly]

That's very cool,  . 

[oldbonz]

you are right, that's maybe too powerful. May I suggest a sightly different version:

the giant helps a meeple cross the outer wall of the city, and therefore the meeple has direct access to the city.
This means when you add a "giant" tile to a city you can place one of your meeples on the city segment EVEN IF the city is already occupied.

Yes I like it,
[mention]oldbonz [/mention] what do you think ?

Well, are you correcting the rule?


Envoyé de mon iPhone en utilisant Tapatalk

[Linksux]

you are right, that's maybe too powerful. May I suggest a sightly different version:

the giant helps a meeple cross the outer wall of the city, and therefore the meeple has direct access to the city.
This means when you add a "giant" tile to a city you can place one of your meeples on the city segment EVEN IF the city is already occupied.

Yes I like it,
[mention]oldbonz [/mention] what do you think ?

Well, are you correcting the rule?


Envoyé de mon iPhone en utilisant Tapatalk

Yes but that’s some work to work on the pdf directly.
I want to make sure about the rule before update


Envoyé de mon iPhone en utilisant Tapatalk

[oldbonz]

you have to think that several giants could be introduced in the game (for now 4)

[Meepledrone]

Another tile for your enjoyment!

[Linksux]

Another tile for your enjoyment!

Thanks Meepledrone, now we got 5

Maybe we can ask Marcel Grober for the others tiles ?
So with all the tiles configuration it will be easier to think about the rules


Envoyé de mon iPhone en utilisant Tapatalk

[Willem]

I'm pretty sure his answer will be no.
The tiles are made personally for the people who were there. Without having their explicit permission, I'm pretty sure he won't send the images out to others, and I doubt he'll reach out to all of them 

He might share how many were made, and we could try to ask on (public) fora if people would like to share theirs?

[Bumsakalaka]

It's look like that there were used only 3 type of tiles CCFF, CFff and CcFf.
Actually, that illustrations are awesome.
Thanks all for sharing.

[Linksux]

I'm pretty sure his answer will be no.
The tiles are made personally for the people who were there. Without having their explicit permission, I'm pretty sure he won't send the images out to others, and I doubt he'll reach out to all of them 

He might share how many were made, and we could try to ask on (public) fora if people would like to share theirs?

Yes you are probably right,

I don't know how to reach as many people as possible.  on the carcassonne fan France group on Facebook only one person shared his tile :-/


Envoyé de mon iPhone en utilisant Tapatalk

[TheDoctor_13]

They drew that AT the festival? Wow thats so detailed and cool! I kind of like the Giant taking over the field rules but excited to see what ideas come about