Carc Central Community > General

Minis Among Us

(1/3) > >>

Whaleyland:
After having a random discussion with kettlefish, I can't help but think it is time for HiG to release a new "Count, King & Cult"-type compilation expansion. CK&C included The River II, The Count, The King, and The Cult. Of those, The Cult was the only new expansion and the other three had previously been released as mini-expansions (with The King being paired with The Scout from Hunters & Gatherers). The total piece count - 36, plus a count token, making this one of the largest expansions to date. In comparison, both The Catapult and Bridges, Castles & Bazaars only included 12 new tiles, though they did include copious amounts of companion wood and cardboard (the catapult, ruler, throwing tokens, bridges, castles).

Since CK&C, they have released Corn Circles (I), The Festival, The Phantom, The School, The Windrose, The Besiegers & The Monasteries. This does not count The River I, which is still generally paired with the base game, or the five Spielbox expansions (Cathars, Cult, Tunnels, Plague, and Little Buildings) that have released over the years.

A breakdown of these HiG expansions is thus:
- Corn Circles (I): 6 tiles
- The Festival: 10 tiles
- The Phantom: 6 Followers
- The School: 2 tiles, 1 Follower
- The Windrose: 6 tiles
- The Besiegers: 6 tiles
- The Monasteries: 6 tiles

Of these, I do not see The School being included as any set since it is a charity expansion. Likewise, I don't think we will see Monasteries as part of an compilation yet since it just released and is currently being distributed as promotional material. That leaves five expansions that could be included in a new Compilation. Together, they would constitute 28 tiles and 6 Followers, which makes an odd number for a tile sheet, which are usually produced in sets of 12.

Thus, what I recommend is that HiG include together Festival, printed with new icons (since the 10th anniversary logo doesn't make as much sense here) and two new tiles, making it an even 12-tile expansion. Add to it The Besiegers (to finally mend the error of the original Cathars distribution), The Phantom (which is out of print and one of the most popular mini expansions), and Corn Circles (I) (also out of print and often confused with the first one). Leave out The Windroses for now but instead include another NEW 12-tile expansion, perhaps something simple or something that would add tiles to previous expansions. Unify all of these with a shared expansion icon and release it as a new combined Expansion 10 called something like "Phantoms & Corn Circles". I would buy it immediately even though I own most of the expansion already.

Any thoughts or ideas regarding a new combination expansion?

Linkback: https://www.carcassonnecentral.com/community/index.php?topic=848.0

asparagus:
You seem worryingly untouched by the plague  http://boardgamegeek.com/boardgameexpansion/85003/carcassonne-the-plague.

Andrew the Ambo:
The Plague is mentioned above, but is put out by Spielbox not HiG.

Whaleyland:
Indeed, Plague was released by Spielbox which has different licensing issues with it and thus is not part of my list. Neither is The Tunnel, The Cathars, The Cult (Spielbox edition), or Little Buildings. This discussion is only about the official Hans im Glueck expansions

asparagus:

--- Quote from: whaleyland on June 23, 2014, 10:39:19 PM ---Indeed, Plague was released by Spielbox which has different licensing issues with it and thus is not part of my list.

--- End quote ---

My bad. Clearly plague on the brain.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page