Carc Central Community > Strategy Guide
Joining Fields
MrNumbers:
--- Quote from: CarcinFool on January 13, 2015, 06:26:54 PM ---Conversely, if you are concerned about your opponent joining fields you can block him. You don’t always need to create a space where no tile will fit, you can also block field-joining by forcing a 3-way road tile (preventing a loop) or placing a city edge adjacent to another city edge.
--- End quote ---
Just wanted to add, that 3-sided road will not 100% pevent fields from joining - there is RRRR tile in I&C, that still can join fields in this situation.
CarcinFool:
Thx MrNumbers -- I did mention that I&C tile in my last paragraph (I referred to it as the 4-way double-curve road), but I will mention that in the discussion about field blocking as well. Good suggestion!
pa3k:
Hey, I saw an add for this T-shirt, and it reminded me of this thread :D
http://bit.ly/1Gxk5iQ
I disagree with the slogan thou, taking fields blocks your settlers forever. How do you guys play it?
danisthirty:
--- Quote from: pa3k on June 23, 2015, 07:13:20 AM ---Hey, I saw an add for this T-shirt, and it reminded me of this thread :D
http://bit.ly/1Gxk5iQ
I disagree with the slogan thou, taking fields blocks your settlers forever. How do you guys play it?
--- End quote ---
Hi pa3k. Welcome to the forums! :)
Simply placing a farmer and expecting everyone else to generate points for you is probably a little bit optimistic (especially if you expect them to generate a winning score for you in doing so), but I guess any detailed analysis of this as genuine tactical advice would undermine the humorous sentiment of the t-shirt!
My personal preference depends on lots of things:
- number of players
- size/ value of field as it is
- potential for growth
- number of meeples available to me after placing my farmer
- number of meeples available to my opponent
- opportunities for getting more farmers into the same farm
- expansions in use (barns especially, but also proximity to towers and/ or the dragon if either of these are in play)
- number of tiles left to be played
Good question though! :(y)
M1zz:
--- Quote from: CarcinFool on January 13, 2015, 06:26:54 PM ---Introduction
Joining fields is a big part of Carcassonne strategy. A single field is often worth a big 9 or 12 points in the base game. If you are playing with expansions that means more tiles, more cities, and possibly field-related bonuses from the pig, pig herd, Cathars, etc. In games with expansions one or more fields can easily be worth upwards of 20 or 30 points. And don't forget those smaller fields -- those are important as well. At the end of a game placing your last meeples on a few small 6-point fields can make all the difference between who wins.
But just as roads and cities can be joined to increase your score or decrease your opponent's, so too can fields be joined with similar results. This article is all about the why and how of joining fields.
Why would I want to join fields?
In your quest to have your farmers supply the most cities (and keep your opponent from supplying very many), there are several scenarios in which you might want to join two or more fields. You might want to...
* Join a field you own to a field your opponent owns (if his has more cities).
* Join two fields that you own to increase the likelihood that you’ll score all the cities on each individual field since you’ll have multiple meeples on the joined field.
* Join two of your opponent’s fields to prevent him from scoring field points twice for any cities that border both fields (See "Being Kind to be Cruel" for an example).
* Pre-emptively join your field to an adjacent unclaimed field to prevent your opponent from using it to steal your field.
* Spoil your opponent’s attempt to join a field she owns by setting up your own join that necessarily occurs when your opponent joins his field (include photo)How can I join fields?
The most common or obvious ways to join fields include connecting fields around the corner of a city and using a cloister with a road to join fields on opposite sides of an existing road.
Using a FFxx tile joining two fields (left) and a cloister with road to join fields on opposite sides of an existing road (right)
But you can also join fields by looping roads, with cleverly placed road curves, or with any tile that has a field that connects opposite sides of the tile. This can take a little practice to spot, but once you see a few examples you’ll be able to identify more opportunities to join fields when you need to.
Joining using a road loop (left) and a tile CFCF with a crosswise field (right)
[add photo of curves like CFRR, CRRF tiles]
Tiles with fields on opposite edges can be used to build multi-tile field “bridges" to connect two separate areas of the board. This situation is less common, but you can sometimes mount a sneak attack by stretching a field over several tiles to join with another field.
[photo of FFFF + FCFC connecting fields on two separate areas of the board]
How can I block my opponent from joining fields that I want to keep separate?
Conversely, if you are concerned about your opponent joining fields you can block him. You don’t always need to create a space where no tile will fit, you can also block field-joining by forcing a 3-way road tile (preventing a loop) or placing a city edge adjacent to another city edge.
Forcing a 3-way road tile to prevent joining with a road elbow (left) and closing off a field with a city (right).
Sometimes blocking your opponent may take two moves, but if the cost would be losing a valuable/critical field (say one worth 30+ points!) it is often worth putting your other projects on hold to focus on blocking your opponent’s field-joining attempt.
How should I choose a spot to join fields so my opponent is less likely to block me?
Try to join fields where your opponent can't place a single tile to restrict or block your attempt. Compare the two situations below. The first attempt can be foiled easily with any tile that has a road while the second cannot. Of course your opponent can place a tile that would allow them to block you on their next turn. If they do, try to ensure your joining attempt can be successful. If you get a helpful tile place it to force the most common tile remaining into the spot where you are joining fields.
[photo of easily blocked field join]
[photo of better field join attempt]
Other related strategies
Another helpful strategy in the early game is to choose where you build your projects to protect any fields you’ve captured early in the game. The opposite also holds true as you can weigh your options for tile placements to help attack a field your opponent has already captured; just make sure the field is worth it.
As the game winds down, be aware of the pieces that are remaining that can help or prevent you from joining. Are there any cloisters with roads left? What about FFxx tiles like FFRR or FFCC? Are there any 3- or 4-way roads that can prevent a looping join? Don’t forget the 4-way double curve road. Also use your knowledge of the remaining tiles to your advantage to block or minimize the chances that your opponent can join fields where it’s advantageous to him. This is pretty apparent when playing on iOS with the option to have the remaining tiles visible, but is much harder in a live game or where this option is disabled.
--- End quote ---
Hello! Why i cant see images?
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[*] Previous page
Go to full version