Since the rule for the flier is older, as is known, we did not know that one day a follower could also be placed as an abbot on the monastery (German monastery). So even if in the rule would have said "monk", this would not exclude the "abbot" on the German monastery. Thus, the flier can choose to land as Monk or Abbot on the German Monastery."Conclusion: if the rule of an older extension speaks only of monk, that does not exclude the abbot on the German monastery.
- An abbot meeple with a monk role placed on an abbey- An abbot meeple placed as a monk on a German monastery- An abbot meeple placed as an abbot on a German monastery- An abbot meeple with a heretic role placed on a shrine- An abbot meeple with an abbot role placed on a garden
If you check this clarification (original text in German, see translation below), it indicates that meeples placed as abbots on a German monastery are still considered monks. This would also apply to other special monasteries such as Dutch & Belgian monasteries or Japanese buildings. http://www.carcassonnecentral.com/community/index.php?topic=781.msg9971#msg9971Here you are the translation into English:QuoteSince the rule for the flier is older, as is known, we did not know that one day a follower could also be placed as an abbot on the monastery (German monastery). So even if in the rule would have said "monk", this would not exclude the "abbot" on the German monastery. Thus, the flier can choose to land as Monk or Abbot on the German Monastery."Conclusion: if the rule of an older extension speaks only of monk, that does not exclude the abbot on the German monastery.
Gradens yes, but not German Cathedrals. In simpler words Inquisition scores for every meeple named Monk, which excludes Heretics and Archbishops.
Started by DavidY
Started by quevy
Started by Allograft
Started by Karcalijn