Carcassonne Central
Carc Central Community => Official Rules => Topic started by: Meepledrone on January 06, 2021, 03:57:26 AM
-
Hi all,
I had a brief exchange with Christof Tisch of HiG about some rules questions. This time we discussed roads, bridges, inns and features affecting tollhouses. I will summarize the answers in following posts.
Following Kettlefish's tradition...
Question in BLUE
Answer in GREEN
Still open in RED
My own comments in MAROON
Cheers!
-
Bridges & Inns
[Q1.] Inns affect those road segments they are on, that is, directly adjacent to. So a bridge placed on a tile with an inn would not be affected by it, since the inn would not be accessible from the bridge. Is this correct? See tile examples from Exp. 8 below.
(https://wikicarpedia.com/images/7/7c/Bridges_Castles_Bazaars_C2_Tile_C.jpg)(https://wikicarpedia.com/images/5/55/Bridges_Castles_Bazaars_C2_Tile_J.jpg)
[A1.] Yes, that is right, the Inn only counts for road which are printed next to it.
But a bridge could count as part of an »inn road« if it is linked to it.
-
Bridges & features affecting tollhouses
[Q2.] If we apply the same principle as in Q1, bridges placed on tiles featuring farmhouses / sheds / highwaymen / gardens would not consider those features when scoring a tollhouse bonus. Is this correct? See tile examples from Exp. 5 and Exp. 8 below.
(https://wikicarpedia.com/images/e/ec/Abbey_And_Mayor_C2_Tile_H.jpg)(https://wikicarpedia.com/images/b/b7/Bridges_Castles_Bazaars_C2_Tile_E.jpg)
[A2.] Yes, that is also right.
-
[Q3.] Inns only affect those road segments they are on, that is, directly adjacent to (the same principle as in Q1). As per the wording of the Tollkeepers rules, the same principle should be applied to farmhouses, sheds,gardens and highwaymen symbols when scoring a tollhouse bonus. Is this correct? Please check the tile examples below, just to check if there is any additional consideration for any of the tiles. Road segments considering features for tollhouse bonuses are marked in green, otherwise in red.
[A3.] As I see it, the marks on the roads are all correct.
-
Example with inns, gardens, tollhouses & bridges
As an additional note, Q1 and Q2 address the scoring question presented in the third image attached:
[Q4.1] Does the road occupied by Blue consider the inns under the bridges? I would say no.
[Q4.2] Do the tollhouses at both ends of the road occupied by Blue consider the garden under the bridge with the Blue Meeple?
[A4.1.] No, the inn under the bridge clearly does not belong or lay beside the road of the Blue Meeple.
[A4.2] In line with the previous answers, the garden does not count for the tollhouses at the end of the road occupied by Blue.
As some may notice, this was a scenario prepared for the Advent Calendar MMXX that I didn't publish, just in case the answer was not the expected one. Finally, this was not the case. ;D