Happy Holidays!After reading the CAR 6.4 on these vacation days, I saw 3 possible corrections:1.- According with the footnote 367 on page 120: If the Festival is used to remove a follower, the Phantom can still be placed on that turn. Is necessary update the Order of Play on page 164, Step 3E, because you don't have to skip the step 4F.2.- On page 172, Other Scoring at the End of the Game, is necessary to include the reference to the 3 points given to feature where the fairy is next to a follower, following the rules on page 483.- After the newer clarifications of The Princess and The Dragon rules, 12/2013, the chart on page 173, relative to the volcano / deployment, must stand that you cannot deploy follower, builder or pig, or could to say may deploy the barn, play a tower piece, deploy a follower to the Wheel of Fortune.
Of course, in looking through the CAR and making the changes, I came across a question of my own. It seems like it had been officially answered before, but I couldn't find the answer. If a player uses the Festival to remove a follower, can he or she still move the fairy? By the spirit of the rules, it seems like the answer is "no" since the Festival ability effectively replaces the move wood phase. However, the rule for the fairy states that the fairy can be moved "when a player does not deploy a follower or [other figure]". Since a figure was not deployed, by the letter of the law this might be legal. Thoughts?
As soon as the feature in question has been scored, the followers involved are removed.
28 - This sentence, based on an FAQ, was added into the RGG rules at a later point in the text.
I'm not sure if this qualifies as errata or not, but the Pig section is rather ambiguous as to whether you can benefit from someone else's pig on a farm you won. It's implied by the fact you only remove the pig when all farmers are gone (in contrast to the builder, which you remove when all your knights or thieves are gone) but it's not very clear.
I suggest to include in The Rivers Section (River I or River II) or like an appendix in the Reference Guide an excellente article written by John Sweeney about The River expansions, with these topics: - What is a "U" turn? - Are you using any extra rules to ensure that the river can be completed?You can read it here: http://www.modernjive.com/carcassonne/carcassonnetheriver.htm Although these are House's Rules, they're a good approach to HiG rules and the most important is I think that this House's Rules are implemented in the Carcassonne iOS App, and this game has a huge player base.
CAR v6.4 - page 15 - rule final scoring and the footnote 28:QuoteAs soon as the feature in question has been scored, the followers involved are removed.Quote28 - This sentence, based on an FAQ, was added into the RGG rules at a later point in the text.This rule is since many years an official rule at HiG.
...Notice how unlike the German rules from HiG it makes no specific mention of the tile with the pig herd (pigsty as ZMG calls it). To me this implies that the pig herd can be scored without playing with the Traders & Builders expansion....
A player who places a dragon tile may deploy a follower or move the fairy as usual. 127 128 Then (before scoring) the game is interrupted129—the dragon is on the move!
Started by aenima
Started by Whaleyland
Started by JT Atomico
Started by Gerry