Question 3:What are the actual rules for the Wheel of Fortune Famine sector? A previous clarification said that the statement “in the same way as farms are scored at final scoring” means that a majority of farmers is required.However, it seems like this is the opposite of the Tax sector, where a majority is NOT required to get the points for knights. Plus, the rule says that the player scores “for each of his FARMERS,” not each farm. It seems like each farmer should score points, and that the “end of game” comment should mean that bonuses are given for pigs, castles, etc. (NOT that a majority is required). I have to say, that I don't know the answer.I think we have some answers at the HiG-Chat or at Spielbox-forum. I have to look.
Question 5 - part 1:When playing with the Robbers, what happens if multiple features are completed at the same time? CAR 6.2 - page 138other rules:• If a robber is on the same space as several counting followers, and more than one of these followers scores points on the same turn, the owner of the robber can choose which counting follower’s points to gets half of.
The German rule says "an/in dessen Wiese" - that means you have to look to whom the farm belonges. That means the normal "farmer scoring" - you have to look for the majority.
Quote from: kettlefish on February 21, 2013, 09:44:00 PMQuestion 5 - part 1:When playing with the Robbers, what happens if multiple features are completed at the same time? CAR 6.2 - page 138other rules:• If a robber is on the same space as several counting followers, and more than one of these followers scores points on the same turn, the owner of the robber can choose which counting follower’s points to gets half of.The rule talks about 1 robber on a space with multiple counting followers that score. What if, though, the same player (a single counting follower) is getting points from more than one feature, such as a city and a road that were completed at the same time? Does the robber get half of the TOTAL points? Or does the robber get half of the points from ONE feature? And if it's only one feature, does the robber player still get to choose?
Each feature scores separated. The robber gets the half of the points for one of the features for scoring.
Quote from: kettlefish on February 26, 2013, 08:43:51 AMEach feature scores separated. The robber gets the half of the points for one of the features for scoring.IMO - Logic would dictate that the Robber can choose which feature to rob - just as he would if there were two players scoring from the same space. One may score a city and one may score a road as a result of the same tile being placed that completes two features at once - the Robber can choose which to rob - he is not only chosing a player to rob but technically, which feature score to rob.
Started by Scott
Started by ac1982
Started by Drodo
Started by emanuele
Started by corinthiens13