Hmm. I remember previous discussion that meeple on watchtower means only on feature witch are detached watchtower. And meeple gets watchtower bonus only if feature on which is staying is finished.Example was meeple on road detached to watchtower and question was if meeple get watchtower bonus if city is finished.Answer was NO, because meeple not staying on finished feature. There were also comparison with original German rules.Now meeple on bridge which is not detached to watchtower is getting watchtower bonus? It has no sense.If I remember garden under bridge is not counted to Toll keepers because of bridge. Anyway meeple on bridge is not on watchtower. He can't get any bonus.Odoslané z SM-A202F pomocou Tapatalku
Well, he adds C1 version to explain what I'm saying before...But If C1 conversion doesn't exist I think that you still wouldn't change your opinion... That's not halfling science...
it [the watchtower] affects "the feature (city or road) on that tile". So I'm not sure how to consider it with bridges. Should we consider a bridge as "the feature on that tile" or not?[...]To me it seems more logical to interpret the watchtowers to be part of the third category, but I may be wrong...
Hmm. I remember previous discussion that meeple on watchtower means only on feature witch are detached watchtower. And meeple gets watchtower bonus only if feature on which is staying is finished.Example was meeple on road detached to watchtower and question was if meeple get watchtower bonus if city is finished.Answer was NO, because meeple not staying on finished feature. There were also comparison with original German rules.Now meeple on bridge which is not detached to watchtower is getting watchtower bonus? It has no sense.If I remember garden under bridge is not counted to Toll keepers because of bridge. Anyway meeple on bridge is not on watchtower. He can't get any bonus.
Scoring modifiers, scoring bonuses and actions affecting a road network will also affect a bridge connected to it:Inns (Exp. 1 - Inns & Cathedrals)Mage (Mini #5 - Mage and Witch)Witch (Mini #5 - Mage and Witch)Solovei Razboynik actions (Russian Promos)German castles (Castles in Germany)German cathedrals (Cathedrals in Germany)Bathhouses (The Barber-Surgeons)Labyrinth bonus (The Labyrinths)Wainwrights quarter bonus (The Markets of Leipzig)Scoring bonuses and actions affecting a tile will also affect a bridge placed on that tile:Dragon eating figures (Exp. 3 - The Princess and the Dragon)Fairy protection (Exp. 3 - The Princess and the Dragon)Watchtower bonus (The Watchtowers): meeples on bridges may trigger the bonus and have to be considered for the watchtower scoring for meeples.Gold pieces (Mini #4 - The Goldmines)Little buildings (Little Buildings)Vodyanoy action (Russian Promos)Scoring bonuses and actions affecting locally printed roads on a tile by proximity (the feature must be on the road) or connectivity (the feature must be connected to the road) will not affect bridges passing over the tile automatically:Inns (Exp. 1 - Inns & Cathedrals)German castles (Castles in Germany)Features considered by tollhouses (The Tollkeepers)Solovei Razboynik action (Russian Promos)
Quote from: Meepledrone on December 27, 2020, 11:33:17 AMI really do appreciate the scholarship involved here but it's thematically disturbing images like this that remind me why I'm not a completionist!!
Quote from: Bumsakalaka on December 28, 2020, 01:45:01 AMHmm. I remember previous discussion that meeple on watchtower means only on feature witch are detached watchtower. And meeple gets watchtower bonus only if feature on which is staying is finished.Example was meeple on road detached to watchtower and question was if meeple get watchtower bonus if city is finished.Answer was NO, because meeple not staying on finished feature. There were also comparison with original German rules.Now meeple on bridge which is not detached to watchtower is getting watchtower bonus? It has no sense.If I remember garden under bridge is not counted to Toll keepers because of bridge. Anyway meeple on bridge is not on watchtower. He can't get any bonus.Odoslané z SM-A202F pomocou TapatalkuYou didn’t understand the rules... Watchtower is an EXTRA BONUS that affects roads or cities of the tile (bridge is a road on the tile). The design of the tiles doesn’t matter. Doesn’t matter if you are close or so far of the watchtower (if you are on the tile). This isn’t scoring bonus, important this!Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
The meeple is on the watchtower but won't score any points for the watchtower until the feature it occupies is completed. That meeple may get the watchtower bonus only once, since it will removed after scoring the watchtower bonus and the road.
Quote from: Bumsakalaka on August 12, 2020, 01:01:59 AMI'm not so good in german but german rules says:Wenn die Straße oder die Stadt eines Meeple auf einem Wachturm-Plättchen abgeschlossen wird, wertest du zuerst den Wachturm und dann die abgeschlossene Straße oder Stadt.That is not correct. "eines Meeple" means "of a meeple". It is the German genitiv, which implies ownership. The meeple 'owns' the city or street in the German sentence. It should be interpreted that the meeple is present on that road or city.
I'm not so good in german but german rules says:Wenn die Straße oder die Stadt eines Meeple auf einem Wachturm-Plättchen abgeschlossen wird, wertest du zuerst den Wachturm und dann die abgeschlossene Straße oder Stadt.
Quote from: DrMeeple on December 28, 2020, 01:58:36 AMQuote from: Bumsakalaka on December 28, 2020, 01:45:01 AMHmm. I remember previous discussion that meeple on watchtower means only on feature witch are detached watchtower. And meeple gets watchtower bonus only if feature on which is staying is finished.Example was meeple on road detached to watchtower and question was if meeple get watchtower bonus if city is finished.Answer was NO, because meeple not staying on finished feature. There were also comparison with original German rules.Now meeple on bridge which is not detached to watchtower is getting watchtower bonus? It has no sense.If I remember garden under bridge is not counted to Toll keepers because of bridge. Anyway meeple on bridge is not on watchtower. He can't get any bonus.Odoslané z SM-A202F pomocou TapatalkuYou didn’t understand the rules... Watchtower is an EXTRA BONUS that affects roads or cities of the tile (bridge is a road on the tile). The design of the tiles doesn’t matter. Doesn’t matter if you are close or so far of the watchtower (if you are on the tile). This isn’t scoring bonus, important this!Sent from my iPad using TapatalkQuote from: DrMeeple on December 28, 2020, 01:58:36 AMQuote from: Bumsakalaka on December 28, 2020, 01:45:01 AMHmm. I remember previous discussion that meeple on watchtower means only on feature witch are detached watchtower. And meeple gets watchtower bonus only if feature on which is staying is finished.Example was meeple on road detached to watchtower and question was if meeple get watchtower bonus if city is finished.Answer was NO, because meeple not staying on finished feature. There were also comparison with original German rules.Now meeple on bridge which is not detached to watchtower is getting watchtower bonus? It has no sense.If I remember garden under bridge is not counted to Toll keepers because of bridge. Anyway meeple on bridge is not on watchtower. He can't get any bonus.Odoslané z SM-A202F pomocou TapatalkuYou didn’t understand the rules... Watchtower is an EXTRA BONUS that affects roads or cities of the tile (bridge is a road on the tile). The design of the tiles doesn’t matter. Doesn’t matter if you are close or so far of the watchtower (if you are on the tile). This isn’t scoring bonus, important this!Sent from my iPad using TapatalkWell. Look here: http://www.carcassonnecentral.com/community/index.php?topic=4750.msg69716#msg69716It was exact example, and I received answer, that Black meeple not get bonus from watchtower because of rules:QuoteThe meeple is on the watchtower but won't score any points for the watchtower until the feature it occupies is completed. That meeple may get the watchtower bonus only once, since it will removed after scoring the watchtower bonus and the road.Quote from: Vital Pluymers on August 12, 2020, 01:21:41 AMQuote from: Bumsakalaka on August 12, 2020, 01:01:59 AMI'm not so good in german but german rules says:Wenn die Straße oder die Stadt eines Meeple auf einem Wachturm-Plättchen abgeschlossen wird, wertest du zuerst den Wachturm und dann die abgeschlossene Straße oder Stadt.That is not correct. "eines Meeple" means "of a meeple". It is the German genitiv, which implies ownership. The meeple 'owns' the city or street in the German sentence. It should be interpreted that the meeple is present on that road or city.
Mmm I see that you don’t want to accept the bonus of the watchtower once on the feature of the meeple of the tile hahaha But as you say you can make house rules because HiG didn’t say anything about it. It’s all about logical about the mini expansion and his rules...Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Hi, here is example and I'm not sure if it's correct.1. Black meaple is not road on watchtower.2. Yellow will finish town on watchtower tileIs this correct crosing?1. Yellow get 4 points for city2. Black get 2 points per city per tile on watch3. Black stays on tile and wait for finish road on which he stays or road before him.- so black can score watchtower tripple times.
Well. Look here: http://www.carcassonnecentral.com/community/index.php?topic=4750.msg69716#msg69716It was exact example, and I received answer, that Black meeple not get bonus from watchtower because of rules:QuoteThe meeple is on the watchtower but won't score any points for the watchtower until the feature it occupies is completed. That meeple may get the watchtower bonus only once, since it will removed after scoring the watchtower bonus and the road.
Answer was that not. Watchtower bonus is only for meeple which stays on finished feature detatched to watchtower.So now I'm confused, because it's 180° turn in rules explenation ;-)
[249.] The tile with ferry was placed by Blue player in a previous turn. Now it is Red's turn. Red place the tile with pigsty. Then Red moves the ferry. Does Red receives a double turn for builder?
Quote from: Carcassonne93 on December 29, 2020, 08:01:21 PM[249.] The tile with ferry was placed by Blue player in a previous turn. Now it is Red's turn. Red place the tile with pigsty. Then Red moves the ferry. Does Red receives a double turn for builder?Extending the road with a new tile would grant Red a double turn in 1. Placing a tile. If later in 2. Placing a meeple, the ferry moves and the road segment on the tile just placed is disconnected from Red's meeple and builder, it doesn't matter because the double turn was already granted.You can revisit the rules for the builder and double turns here:https://wikicarpedia.com/index.php/Traders_and_Builders#1._Placing_a_tile_and_getting_a_double_turn
3.Extra Abbey RoundIf any abbey tiles have not been placed, proceed with one more round to allow all players to place them
[250.] When going accross the game reference page on WICA, selecting all expansions, I came accross this action, at the end of the game, when there is no tiles left:Quote3.Extra Abbey RoundIf any abbey tiles have not been placed, proceed with one more round to allow all players to place themWhere do this rule come from? I find it really interesting, but I couldn't find it in the Abbey & Mayor expansion page (rules and footnotes), and also not in the order of play.
If one or more players have not yet placed their Abbey tiles when the last landscape tile is drawn and placed, they may now do so, if possible, in clockwise order starting from the left of the person who placed the last tile. Then, the game ends.
Started by walt_ua
Started by DIN0
Started by DaFees
Started by Meepledrone
Started by TGD