Your suspicion is correct. It should have an effect, if mage or witch has been moved.
Quote from: kettlefish on May 05, 2014, 09:38:57 AMYour suspicion is correct. It should have an effect, if mage or witch has been moved.Moving from tile to tile, or from feature to feature, will have an impact on the game.Does this answer really resolve the issue? Seems kind of vague to me....
Quote from: rfielder on May 06, 2014, 05:57:17 AMQuote from: kettlefish on May 05, 2014, 09:38:57 AMYour suspicion is correct. It should have an effect, if mage or witch has been moved.Moving from tile to tile, or from feature to feature, will have an impact on the game.Does this answer really resolve the issue? Seems kind of vague to me....I think this does resolve the issue. HiG is stating that movement of the Mage or Witch should have an effect, i.e. should change something about the game state. If the Mage or Witch just moves to a different tile of the same feature, there is no real change. Thus, the requirement would be that the move has to be to a different feature.
I personally go with the HiG version of the rule: figure. This makes the Festival more specific. The "new" rule is from the CundCo Shop. I've sent my reply to HiG... Some weeks ago Georg Wild (HiG) told me that he also prefers the original version of the rule which came out together with the jubilee edition.
Question 1c - HillsWhat if red has two followers on hills and blue has only one follower on a hill? Can the tie-breaking effect of hills be stacked?We still discuss this situation... - no answer yet...
Quote from: kettlefish on May 05, 2014, 10:50:30 AMI personally go with the HiG version of the rule: figure. This makes the Festival more specific. The "new" rule is from the CundCo Shop. I've sent my reply to HiG... Some weeks ago Georg Wild (HiG) told me that he also prefers the original version of the rule which came out together with the jubilee edition.I'm confused on this one kettlefish. Aren't these answers coming from HiG? But you are saying you personally go with the HiG version. It seems redundant.
Started by kettlefish
Started by Meepledrone