A couple of images illustrating how the chin reaction is broken by the third castle from the left. The arrows indicate the feature(s) the castle may score the points for.Example 1: the fief of the third castle does not overlap the second, so it cannot spread the chain reaction.Example 2: the fief of the third castle does not overlap the second and it is already completed, so it cannot spread the chain reaction either.
A couple of images illustrating how the chain reaction is broken by the third castle from the left. The arrows indicate the feature(s) the castle may score the points for.Example 1: the fief of the third castle does not overlap the second castle, so it cannot spread the chain reaction.Example 2: the fief of the third castle does not overlap the second castle and it is already completed, so it cannot spread the chain reaction either.
‘So the second example is impossible, unless that meeple was removed by a festival.‘Exactly. Obviously there are ways that I know of that situation.The fact is that the sentence of the official rules if the German term is interpreted as in any of the 6 tiles, absurd ways of scoring could be given as the last examples that I have put. Which personally contradict the main rules of a castle and its 6 tiles.If finally HiG really clarifies what it had in mind with that sentence (I think it would have been good to put an image in the official rules) and it is like that, it would be another example of the nonsense that it carries behind its back ... Like the new rules for the halflings, German castles or the C2 wagon ... Not being an official is going to make more sense.And if in the end they literally wanted to say ‘next to’, that "chain reaction" it would be more difficult for it to happen and the game would be somewhat more balanced ...
Quote from: Meepledrone on January 05, 2021, 03:59:16 AMA couple of images illustrating how the chin reaction is broken by the third castle from the left. The arrows indicate the feature(s) the castle may score the points for.Example 1: the fief of the third castle does not overlap the second, so it cannot spread the chain reaction.Example 2: the fief of the third castle does not overlap the second and it is already completed, so it cannot spread the chain reaction either.I did't look to image seriously and I didn't figure that castle is rurned at 90°.
Quote from: Meepledrone on January 05, 2021, 03:59:16 AMA couple of images illustrating how the chain reaction is broken by the third castle from the left. The arrows indicate the feature(s) the castle may score the points for.Example 1: the fief of the third castle does not overlap the second castle, so it cannot spread the chain reaction.Example 2: the fief of the third castle does not overlap the second castle and it is already completed, so it cannot spread the chain reaction either.Now that I think about it ... I think you have opened the door to another discussion hahahaBecause yes, the castle is in the fief of the first ... And then there would be the question of what you base it on to say that a fief yes and another no when the official sentence doesn’t go beyond haha this is already speculation haha
Quote from: Vital Pluymers on January 05, 2021, 04:16:22 AMI was too quick with my reply too But Meepledrone's conclusion is correct.Yes, but still didn't know is it will overlaps if chain will containus or not. I think yes. If not, it will be in rules, like stop of "tripple" turn for Builder.
I was too quick with my reply too But Meepledrone's conclusion is correct.
Quote from: DrMeeple on January 05, 2021, 04:12:10 AMQuote from: Meepledrone on January 05, 2021, 03:59:16 AMA couple of images illustrating how the chain reaction is broken by the third castle from the left. The arrows indicate the feature(s) the castle may score the points for.Example 1: the fief of the third castle does not overlap the second castle, so it cannot spread the chain reaction.Example 2: the fief of the third castle does not overlap the second castle and it is already completed, so it cannot spread the chain reaction either.Now that I think about it ... I think you have opened the door to another discussion hahahaBecause yes, the castle is in the fief of the first ... And then there would be the question of what you base it on to say that a fief yes and another no when the official sentence doesn’t go beyond haha this is already speculation hahaDr. Meeple, as far as I can see, you are the only one with doubts...
This will be fun: We began to open speculation to infinity and beyond hahaha ...
Meepledrone did not write that the fiefs should overlap. Meepledrone has written that the fief should overlap the feature. In these examples the feature happens to be a castle.That is just another way of saying that the feature should be located in the castle's fief as per the original rules.Quote from: DrMeeple on January 05, 2021, 04:12:10 AMThis will be fun: We began to open speculation to infinity and beyond hahaha ...I think this summarizes the overall purpose of your discussion.It seems that you just like to discuss, whether it contributes anything or not...
Quote from: Vital Pluymers on January 05, 2021, 05:28:46 AMMeepledrone did not write that the fiefs should overlap. Meepledrone has written that the fief should overlap the feature. In these examples the feature happens to be a castle.That is just another way of saying that the feature should be located in the castle's fief as per the original rules.Quote from: DrMeeple on January 05, 2021, 04:12:10 AMThis will be fun: We began to open speculation to infinity and beyond hahaha ...I think this summarizes the overall purpose of your discussion.It seems that you just like to discuss, whether it contributes anything or not...With my understanding of the rules, I do totally agree with Meepledrone and Vital Pluymers And yes, the purpose of this discussion seems to be turning in circles. Even if the original questions were good ones, they've already been clarified but it seems the clarifications doesn't matter here
As a castle owner you also get points for a completed feature (no farm), if nobody scores this completed feature. So the points for the castle do not depend on the points someone gets when a completed feature is scored.
Started by JGreystone
Started by danisthirty
Started by PapaGeek
Started by Paul
Started by RitaC