Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - Bumsakalaka

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 106
1
Official Rules / Re: Princess and remove a meeple
« on: March 11, 2024, 12:20:32 PM »
Hi guys,

When you lay a tile with the princess in a city where there are for example the big meeple and 'normal' meeple of your opponent, which should be removed?

kind regards
Marco

This is your decision which you will remove. I recommend to take large one.

Quote
If a Princess tile continues a city occupied by one or more knights, you may remove one knight of your choice (even your own) from the continued city and return it to its player's supply.
Lage Meeple is also Knight with power 2 for scoring purposes, but it is still knight.

2
We excluded the Fairy bonus from scorings taking place in 2. Placing a meeple because it is triggered by the scoring of tile-based features in 3. Scoring a feature.
Main reason for excluding was, that you are scoring Fairy and not meeple.

4
General / Re: The Ballad of Carcassonne
« on: February 21, 2024, 12:24:02 PM »
Amazing job, we have an anthem! @Meepledrone this should be on main page :)

Merit!

5
Unofficial Rules / Re: New general rule for The Wells
« on: February 19, 2024, 01:07:04 PM »
Whenever possible, I would prefer a wording indicating that any given expansion adds +1 point per well. Expansions normally do that to the number of points a coat of arms or a tile is worth. In the basic case, going from 1 point to 2 points can be seen as doubling the value when it it just adding +1 point.

Yah I know, but here we are
1. Inns - When a player completes a road with one or more inns, the scoring player(s) receive each 2 points per tile forming this completed road (instead of the usual 1 point per tile).
2. German Cathedrals - When you complete a road leading directly to a cathedral your highwayman/traveler gives you 2 points for each road tile the road consist of.

So we play it as 1 + 1 + 1.

And as I wrote. This is general rule for new expansions and for expansions author doesn't know. And explicitly exclude Mage from this (which as we know, are getting bonus only for tiles in the city and not for the coat of arms). So +1 per tile is not enough for get that bonus also for well.

6
Official Rules / Re: Moving the fairy (castles and wagons)
« on: February 19, 2024, 06:08:14 AM »
Case #1: The fairy is assigned to a meeple placed on a 1-tile city. What happens to the fairy if that 1-tile city turns into a castle?

Not a clarification yet for this case on any of the sources I checked back in the day. My current understanding is that the fairy should move to the castle along with the meeple. Rmoving the fairy seems too drastci and leaving it behind on the tile sounds very odd.


Is there already a final conclusion regarding this case?
If the fairy joins the meeple to the castle, which tiles if any are protected against the dragon?
Both, the one the fairy was standing on originally or none (as the fairy is in the castle and not on the tile anymore)?

By me? None. As you told, tile is not on tile, it's on castle token, which is not part of tile, and this is reason, why meeple on castle is protected by Castle against Dragon at all.

7
Same time @wolnic - release is good :)

8
On this page: https://wikicarpedia.com/car/Scoring:_A_Historical_Perspective_(1st_edition)

The first diagram is labelled "1st score, 2nd score, 3rd score". For consistency with the main text it should be labelled, "1st edition, 2nd edition, 3rd edition".

Well, when usually C2 is marked as 2nd edition and C3 as 3rd edition of Carcassonne, then it will be better to name as 1st version rules, 2nd version rules and 3rd version rules.

It better than confusing 1st edition rules of 1st edition of Carcassonne, 2nd edition rules of 1st edition of Carcassonne, etc.

This have no impact to Editions (C1/C2/C3), but to rules adaptation in specific Cx edition.

9
Unofficial Rules / Re: New general rule for The Wells
« on: February 15, 2024, 12:49:46 AM »
@meepleater what do you think about this General rule:

When any feature doubles, triples, or has any other multiplier for each tile of the road, the same effect occurs with the value of the well.

This solution if fine, because it excludes Mage expansion from this definition, because Mage works only with tiles and not with coat of arms (pennants).

I think that sounds good

Ok. WikiCarpedia updated.

10
Unofficial Rules / Re: New general rule for The Wells
« on: February 14, 2024, 05:22:48 AM »
@meepleater what do you think about this General rule:

When any feature doubles, triples, or has any other multiplier for each tile of the road, the same effect occurs with the value of the well.

This solution if fine, because it excludes Mage expansion from this definition, because Mage works only with tiles and not with coat of arms (pennants).

11
Unofficial Rules / Re: New general rule for The Wells
« on: February 13, 2024, 08:34:14 AM »
So my question is:
Made this as "general rules" which can be used for other expansion which were not released in time when original expansion The Wells was released, or was unknown for author of fan-expansion?


If yes, then for German Cathedrals, road leading to German Cathedrar has to increase also value of each well on that road.


What do you think @meepleater (this is autor of original The Wells expansion - https://wikicarpedia.com/car/The_Wells_(Fan_Expansion)
and @wolnic (author of Wells 2)?

I’m not sure I understand the phrasing of the question, but my intention was for wells to function the same way as pennants in cities do, so a feature that would increase the value of a pennant in a city would also increase the value of a well on a road.

I’m not sure I can speak for all fan expansions since I’m not familiar with them all, I think it would come down to whatever makes the most logical sense in a given case.

Thanks @meepleater for quick response.

So just for confirmation.

German Cathedrals grant double points for each tile like Inns.
Well on road connected to German Cathedral will score 2, wouldn't?

12
Official Rules / Re: French version of the rules in pdf
« on: February 11, 2024, 12:05:48 PM »
Och I see, @Gagoune he mark it as pre-release.
Check here: https://github.com/farin/JCloisterZone-Client/releases
Same pb: unknown language... I enter in the preferences but impossible to put it in another language...
EDIT : OK, done it in english! Sorry! I tried with the French language..

Hi, I forgot to write to you, that it's fixed.

13
Unofficial Rules / New general rule for The Wells
« on: February 11, 2024, 03:40:07 AM »
We are trying in Fan Expansions complete rules section on WikiCarpedia (https://wikicarpedia.com/car/Fan_Expansions) to made all covered expansion compatible and playable with other expansion and covered fan expansion with explain all possible interactions.


So I found issue with The Wells.


If there is road with Inn then well get double score.
If there is road with Stable (from fan expansion Roads to Vistory) then well get double score. 


So it has sense for me (and as we spoke on Discord also with @Snearone and @Meepledrone ), it has like coat of arms (pennant) of road.
So if some expansion increase value of each tile of feature (here the road), then it's increased also value of each well on road.


So my question is:
Made this as "general rules" which can be used for other expansion which were not released in time when original expansion The Wells was released, or was unknown for author of fan-expansion?


If yes, then for German Cathedrals, road leading to German Cathedrar has to increase also value of each well on that road.


What do you think @meepleater (this is autor of original The Wells expansion - https://wikicarpedia.com/car/The_Wells_(Fan_Expansion)
and @wolnic (author of Wells 2)?

14
General / Re: Problems with WICA
« on: February 06, 2024, 07:24:31 AM »
It can be some PHP issue. Need to debug on server side. White screen of death usually PHP Fatal Error.
Let me know if you’re not able to reproduce the problem on some device. I’m often sharing my laptop screen on Discord so easy enough if you need me as a testing guinea pig.
This is not possible to reproduce. Sometimes, it heed specific configuration. So @Sinscerly please can you manage this. This needs to be done directly from console.

15
General / Re: Problems with WICA
« on: February 06, 2024, 06:07:54 AM »
It can be some PHP issue. Need to debug on server side. White screen of death usually PHP Fatal Error.

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 106