Carcassonne Central
Carc Central Community => General => Topic started by: Bumsakalaka on March 26, 2021, 02:22:46 AM
-
These rules are published direct on mindok (publisher) web page. So I guess it's in print and will not changed. But as some "old C1 stuff" still in rules, their translator uses previous transations and not check rules ganes by HiG :( So there is issue, that player has to show tile to other players when he take if from stack. In C2 rules is not required (read: it is not written anywhere that player has to show).
I think this "issue" is going to be of little concern to casual Carcassonne players. It's hard to imagine anyone losing any sleep or having a game ruined over whether they should or shouldn't show their tile to their opponents before placing it. It's not like they're not going to see it anyway.
This was only one. For example in czech rules:
1. Abbey C2 still able to place when possible and wanted by player after placed last tile from stack
2. Fairy is not allowed to place next to Big Meeple, Wagon, Mayor etc. - this one is the best :D
-
Each licensed publisher is free to publish the rules for their region as they wish. These differences are a decisions made by each license holder to best suite their customers.
-
And also nothing to do with the anniversary expansion, so I'm splitting this topic.
-
These rules are published direct on mindok (publisher) web page. So I guess it's in print and will not changed. But as some "old C1 stuff" still in rules, their translator uses previous transations and not check rules ganes by HiG :( So there is issue, that player has to show tile to other players when he take if from stack. In C2 rules is not required (read: it is not written anywhere that player has to show).
I think this "issue" is going to be of little concern to casual Carcassonne players. It's hard to imagine anyone losing any sleep or having a game ruined over whether they should or shouldn't show their tile to their opponents before placing it. It's not like they're not going to see it anyway.
This was only one. For example in czech rules:
1. Abbey C2 still able to place when possible and wanted by player after placed last tile from stack
2. Fairy is not allowed to place next to Big Meeple, Wagon, Mayor etc. - this one is the best :D
In that case I apologise. I hadn't realised that there were already plans to release Inns & Cathedrals, Princess & Dragon and Abbey & Mayor in a format that is compatible with these new UV tiles.
-
These rules are published direct on mindok (publisher) web page. So I guess it's in print and will not changed. But as some "old C1 stuff" still in rules, their translator uses previous transations and not check rules ganes by HiG :( So there is issue, that player has to show tile to other players when he take if from stack. In C2 rules is not required (read: it is not written anywhere that player has to show).
I think this "issue" is going to be of little concern to casual Carcassonne players. It's hard to imagine anyone losing any sleep or having a game ruined over whether they should or shouldn't show their tile to their opponents before placing it. It's not like they're not going to see it anyway.
This was only one. For example in czech rules:
1. Abbey C2 still able to place when possible and wanted by player after placed last tile from stack
2. Fairy is not allowed to place next to Big Meeple, Wagon, Mayor etc. - this one is the best :D
In that case I apologise. I hadn't realised that there were already plans to release Inns & Cathedrals, Princess & Dragon and Abbey & Mayor in a format that is compatible with these new UV tiles.
It's starting to look like there may well have been plans already in place Dan! ;)
-
These rules are published direct on mindok (publisher) web page. So I guess it's in print and will not changed. But as some "old C1 stuff" still in rules, their translator uses previous transations and not check rules ganes by HiG :( So there is issue, that player has to show tile to other players when he take if from stack. In C2 rules is not required (read: it is not written anywhere that player has to show).
I think this "issue" is going to be of little concern to casual Carcassonne players. It's hard to imagine anyone losing any sleep or having a game ruined over whether they should or shouldn't show their tile to their opponents before placing it. It's not like they're not going to see it anyway.
This was only one. For example in czech rules:
1. Abbey C2 still able to place when possible and wanted by player after placed last tile from stack
2. Fairy is not allowed to place next to Big Meeple, Wagon, Mayor etc. - this one is the best :D
In that case I apologise. I hadn't realised that there were already plans to release Inns & Cathedrals, Princess & Dragon and Abbey & Mayor in a format that is compatible with these new UV tiles.
It's starting to look like there may well have been plans already in place Dan! ;)
If only I'd known. I feel so foolish! :-[
-
These rules are published direct on mindok (publisher) web page. So I guess it's in print and will not changed. But as some "old C1 stuff" still in rules, their translator uses previous transations and not check rules ganes by HiG :( So there is issue, that player has to show tile to other players when he take if from stack. In C2 rules is not required (read: it is not written anywhere that player has to show).
I think this "issue" is going to be of little concern to casual Carcassonne players. It's hard to imagine anyone losing any sleep or having a game ruined over whether they should or shouldn't show their tile to their opponents before placing it. It's not like they're not going to see it anyway.
This was only one. For example in czech rules:
1. Abbey C2 still able to place when possible and wanted by player after placed last tile from stack
2. Fairy is not allowed to place next to Big Meeple, Wagon, Mayor etc. - this one is the best :D
In that case I apologise. I hadn't realised that there were already plans to release Inns & Cathedrals, Princess & Dragon and Abbey & Mayor in a format that is compatible with these new UV tiles.
It's starting to look like there may well have been plans already in place Dan! ;)
If only I'd known. I feel so foolish! :-[
It’s starting to look like my comment, although a week later, may still have been too early emoji code57] only I could manage that emoji code1787]
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk