Carcassonne Central
Carc Central Community => Unofficial Rules => Topic started by: burtonlazars on December 30, 2019, 11:54:23 AM
-
The general rules for placing meeples, including knights, is that you may not place one in a feature where there is already at least one other meeple.
However if we consider a mayor that is occupying a city with no shields/pennants/coat of arms, the mayor has 0 strength and therefore has no claim to the city.
I propose therefore that a knight may be placed in a city that is already occupied by a mayor (belonging to either you or an opponent), provided it has 0 strength.
-
The general rules for placing meeples, including knights, is that you may not place one in a feature where there is already at least one other meeple.
However if we consider a mayor that is occupying a city with no shields/pennants/coat of arms, the mayor has 0 strength and therefore has no claim to the city.
I propose therefore that a knight may be placed in a city that is already occupied by a mayor (belonging to either you or an opponent), provided it has 0 strength.
See the rules on wikicarpedia you will see that you can’t do that.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
Hi burtonlazars!
Congratulations for your first post.
Permiting the addition of mayors to ocuppied cities with no pennants could be a house rule.
Have you tried it yourself? It could become a cutthroat mechanic to take over cities by starting slow. >:D
Cheers!
-
Hi burtonlazars!
Congratulations for your first post.
Permiting the addition of mayors to ocuppied cities with no pennants could be a house rule.
Have you tried it yourself? It could become a cutthroat mechanic to take over cities by starting slow. >:D
Cheers!
Using a Mayor in a city without pennants makes no sense... emoji code12]
Enviado desde mi XT1700 mediante Tapatalk
-
As a final stage, it doesn't. But what if you send the mayor in a diplomatic mission to take over the city? >:D
-
As a final stage, it doesn't. But what if you send the mayor in a diplomatic mission to take over the city? >:D
Take over a city with a lot of pennants you mean. emoji code12]
Enviado desde mi XT1700 mediante Tapatalk
-
You inflitrate your Mayor in a promissing city with no pennants and then you start to add tiles with pennants to avoid other players to take over while your Mayor grows in strength. Totally evil! >:D
-
You inflitrate your Mayor in a promissing city with no pennants and then you start to add tiles with pennants to avoid other players to take over while your Mayor grows in strength. Totally evil! >:D
You could do this but for me it’s too much risking... Maybe you can’t do that if someone takes the tiles that you are waiting for... Or if someone put a CCFF or CCRR without pennant and connect the castle and takes all the points for him...
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
Welcome to the forum Burtonlazars,
An interesting suggestion, however, the 'official' rules are clear on this matter:
http://wikicarpedia.com/index.php/Abbey_and_the_Mayor_(1st_edition)#Deploy_a_follower_2
I've moved this thread to the unofficial rules forum, for the discussion to continue.