Why I find no answer here is as follows:The gold piece concerns a whole tile.Rule gold mines:"This a piece of gold is never assigned to a particular building,but always applies to all buildings on a tile."However, the castle is in the middle of 2 tiles. (see below *)A road and a city comprised of several segments andthe cloister consists of the cloister tile and the 8 adjacent tiles.The same as at the cloister applies to the castle?Rules castle - definition of the environment:The environment tiles are the 2 tiles, on which rests the castle, as well as the 2 tiles right and the 2 tiles left them--so a total of 6 tiles.* So, the castle is located on 2 tiles, not on a particular tile.Can the castle ever get a piece of gold?
* So, the castle is located on 2 tiles, not on a particular tile.Can the castle ever get a piece of gold?
Rules castle - definition of the environment:The environment tiles are the 2 tiles, on which rests the castle, as well as the 2 tiles right and the 2 tiles left them--so a total of 6 tiles.
Quote from: Carcking on May 31, 2013, 01:08:04 PMIt's a question of how the castle mechanic works. Does the castle grant a share of the ownership of the triggering feature to the owner of the castle? Or do the two remain completely independent?The scoring for the castle has nothing to do with the "ownership" of that feature. The castle gets points only for "how many points is that finished feature worth?". The castle score also for a finished feature that was not occupied by any follower. (see the picture "Burg und Goldmine2.jpg")
It's a question of how the castle mechanic works. Does the castle grant a share of the ownership of the triggering feature to the owner of the castle? Or do the two remain completely independent?
In my opinion also a castle can take over and all gold pieces, which are located in the Castle area gold pieces. 6 tiles are the castle environment: the two on which the castle was built both right and left, both of which. From there, the owner of the castle can take pieces of gold.There are several players that have eligible for gold, gold is distributed round robin one after the other, as it usually is.I hope that answers your question (s).I have looked at times just watching the thread. Option 1 is in my opinion the wisest and one that corresponds to the game.
Well done on following up with HiG! :-) And the translation seems to be straightforward.From what he says I would understand that to mean that any gold on the six tiles in vicinity of the castle are available to be taken by the owner of the castle. So the gold lying outside those six tiles and lying on Blue's castle are not available for Red to collect. But any gold that is on an incomplete feature, but within Red's six tiles, are available to be taken by Red.
This is very different to the my thoughts! :-) I suppose Christof Tisch would think them much too narrow an interpretation of the rules. Oh well. It's good to get these things clarified!By the way kettlefish, how well does my writing translate to German?
obervet03,should I post all the answers for the pictures in the same posts (modify each post) where the pictures are?
Started by MrNumbers
Started by Whaleyland
Started by Mikki1211
Started by danisthirty
Started by Windekind