Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - nl42247

Pages: [1]
1
General / Re: cardboard upgraded to wood
« on: February 24, 2014, 10:19:46 AM »
I could be mistaken with the teacher, I saw them offered together on ebay the school with wooden teacher several times so I assumed that there were different original teachers. Could also be that those sellers had the same feeling about the plastic teacher and their for replaced it.

I'm aware of the different sheep tokens that's why I'm still not sure what to do with them. I think I try the expansion as it is first and decide later.

2
General / Re: cardboard upgraded to wood
« on: February 23, 2014, 03:09:27 PM »
We got the same mental problem. I thought about the plague before but couldn't come up with a good solution and I couldn't find a nice wooden token for the red trade good the cloth I think it is. I found the grain and barrel but couldn't settle for a red token I didn't like also color confusion with red player. So on that point I stuck to cardboard. The tiles I can live with by now, took some time.

I'm curious to your plague solution please post a picture.

All of the wooden pieces I got from 1 web shop www.spelspul.nl  it's in The Netherlands and it's all in Dutch but if you want I can help you contact the owner. It wasn't that expensive all the wooden pieces together maybe 10 15 euro about 15 20 USD. They ship cheap.




3
General / Re: cardboard upgraded to wood
« on: February 23, 2014, 12:52:04 PM »
and another

4
General / Re: cardboard upgraded to wood
« on: February 23, 2014, 12:51:25 PM »
next one

5
General / Re: cardboard upgraded to wood
« on: February 23, 2014, 12:48:34 PM »
first 2 pictures

6
General / cardboard upgraded to wood
« on: February 23, 2014, 09:49:11 AM »
I thought all that cardboard on the playing field made things confusing.
You should be able to see everything what's going on on the board in the blink of an eye. Or at least don't overlook things easily.
there for I changed some elements of the game from cardboard to wood.

I replaced castles, little buildings (houses), tunnel chips, the phantom and the teacher.
The teacher doesn't really count I suppose because it came already as an wooden figure in some packs of the school,
of course I was lucky enough to get that acryl phantom looking teacher instead of the nice wooden one But it's wood now so no crying.

All neutral pieces like little buildings (houses) and  castles I replaced with white wooden pieces because white isn't a standard color,
and let's be honest even if you added white pieces to your collection how many times you got that many players around the table?
And it isn't that easy to find all parts you want in a certain color so that's why it's white I preferred brown myself because of the towers and bridges.

The phantom I didn't even buy because I disliked the plastic that much but I found something in each color that did the trick.

Tunnels got changed right away to because of the red chips with the plague, maybe not nessecary, now the tiny things won't get lost  I tell myself.

Here some pictures (if I did it right) IN ANOTHER TOPIC WAS TO BIG

I did not replace the cardboard of the plague, because of confusing with the player red, and more importantly you would have to sticker them or write on them because of their different sides.

I was thinking about a pink pig for the pigs on the river tile, we sometime forget to count those so that would make it easier to remember.
And I'm not sure what to do with the new expansion shepard and hills (maybe not correct translation).
You still need the sheep and wolf to make an honest draw, but I already looked at wooden white sheep and found them. But will the board be getting to crowded then? The wolf is optional because it would never come on the board anyway. Maybe I just have to go with the cardboard like the plague, don't know yet.

And the cardboard from the catapult expansion, well every word you say about that one is a complete waste of your time.
I Just us the tiles it has some nice roads in it. The catapult itself is banned to the box with spare parts and things of the original game what i can't stand nor trow away.

7
Official Rules / Re: rules with more expansions
« on: February 23, 2014, 01:02:22 AM »
thanks for the quick answer, it confirmed what i thought but its better to be certain.
I see that i mixed up some terms in the question (follower/ meeple and phantom / follower) sorry for that,
English isnt my first language. sometimes it gets confusing with translating.
you will be hearing from me more often.
thanks

8
Official Rules / rules with more expansions
« on: February 22, 2014, 01:04:32 PM »
we were playing with almost all expansions

question 1 wheel of fortune

Does a special meeple count as a knight thief farmer or monk?
what we did> the big meeple from i&c counts for 2 meeples
                    >wagon and follower as 1 meeple
                    >shed and pig is no farmer
                    >builder is no meeple
So far everyone was happy but the mayor was the real problem we had 3 opinions
>mayor counts as 1
>mayor counts as 0
>mayor counts for every weapon in the city
With last option you get absurt high points so that cant be right but my city building friend doesnt believe me untill i have an official reply

question 2 castle and bridges

when you finish a road with a bridge in it, does the bridge count as a tile (the one it overlapse) and when a bridge goes over a tile whats already part of the road does this tile count as 1 point or an additinol point for the bridge?

question 3 castle and bridges

when you own a cit and you build a castle next to it with the same tile as you finish your big city, do you score just the city and keep the castle or do you score the city and score the castle so double points?

question 4 the tunnels

When placing a tunnel chip do you have to put both chips in the same turn? Or may you only 1 or can you choose wether you play 1, 2 or none at all? can you play a tunnelchip on a road somebody else owns?

question 5 the ferries

when you put down a ferry tile do you have the choise to put down a ferry or no ferry when you dont put down a meeple?
And when is a road finished as soon as you put down the ferry tile with the lake or when you put the ferry on it so it stays incomplete  or finishes?

Pages: [1]