Where in the official rules does it state that the City of Carcassonne is counted for farming?
The city of Carcassonne does count when scoring farms at the end of the game.
Quote from: 24hourpartymeeple on November 28, 2013, 05:24:01 AMWhere in the official rules does it state that the City of Carcassonne is counted for farming?Footnote Nr. 68:Code: [Select]The city of Carcassonne does count when scoring farms at the end of the game.
@24hourpartymeeple, lots and lots of stuff in the CAR is not in the official rules that come with the expansions. That's kind of the point
Quote from: JT Atomico on November 29, 2013, 09:40:59 AM@24hourpartymeeple, lots and lots of stuff in the CAR is not in the official rules that come with the expansions. That's kind of the point I get what you're saying and I'm glad the CAR exists but I'm willing to bet that only a fraction (say, 5%) of players know of it and check it for rulings. Average players and families will not use that rule (or others in the CAR but not in the physical rules) when they play. I just think that if its a rule it should be in the included rules.
Quote from: 24hourpartymeeple on November 29, 2013, 11:37:26 AMQuote from: JT Atomico on November 29, 2013, 09:40:59 AM@24hourpartymeeple, lots and lots of stuff in the CAR is not in the official rules that come with the expansions. That's kind of the point I get what you're saying and I'm glad the CAR exists but I'm willing to bet that only a fraction (say, 5%) of players know of it and check it for rulings. Average players and families will not use that rule (or others in the CAR but not in the physical rules) when they play. I just think that if its a rule it should be in the included rules.I think that a lot of questions appears when the people plays with some expansion and they find singular situations. It's too hard try to imagine all possible scenarios when the publishers are planning the new expansions and writing the rules. You help to build a game playing it.This is another reason to promove in other forums the wonderful CAR.
I've never seen such intense debate over a single point. As evmillan said, our hope is that more people will be made aware of the CAR and make use of it when they play. It's not cost-effective for the publishers to improve the printed rules to the same level of quality as the CAR, so we'll be in business for a very long time.
I had a short telephone call with Georg Wild - HiG - today:The city of Carcassonne does count when scoring the points for the king and also when scoring for farms at the end of the game.
Started by JoeSesquipedalian
Started by GodSiGmaR
Started by nblack27
Started by raged_norm
Started by mPony